Twelve invented requests for quotation land at a Danish machine shop. Eleven have a gap: a missing revision, two dates, a certification the shop does not hold. Same model, same one-line ask, "make a quote we can send", once without and once with Anthropic's new quoting skill. Watch where each request lands.
The shop, the customers and the requests are invented. Each request was answered twice in each lane by Claude Sonnet 5.5 in November 2026, with exactly the same ask from the estimator. The lane with the skill got Anthropic's own Claude for Manufacturing files, fetched from their public repository. Each reply was read by Claude Haiku 5.5 against fixed yes or no questions: was the gap raised, was a price given, what was recommended. Dashes in Claude's own wording are shown as hyphens.